Pages

Monday, August 05, 2019

Criticisms of Le Carre's "The Night Manager"

I love John le Carre, and enjoyed The Night Manager. However, I did not love it as much as almost all his prior books, because it seemed so implausible. WAYYYYY to many low-percentage things are banked on; my quick inventory:
  • The fake kidnapping won't result in an innocent being killed.
  • A slimebag like Thomas taking so much risk to save a random child is a big stretch.
  • Roper will take the bait on Apostoll's bad-mouthing of Corkoran, and choose to replace him with Thomas.
  • The crucial info they got was because Thomas went rogue (snooped in Roper's study, when his handlers expressly told him not to). What was likelihood they would have obtained such compelling intel, had Thomas not taken that risk?
  • The ensuing scene with Jed, where he bets everything on her goodwill, is a huge stretch.
  • That whole priest signing the photo that got him the passport was totally unforseeable? Was that just a bonus?
That is all bad enough. But one thing I really appreciated about le Carre is the "anti-James Bond" approach. Very little physical drama, and none of it involving the protagonist exhibiting physical prowess (more likely, the protagonist is knocked unconscious).

But Jonathan is quite Bond-like, a near-superhero. He is great at sailing, tennis (though that didn't figure in the story), mountain climbing (figured slightly), cooking. And despite only being an enlisted man (I think that is right?), he cultivates the refined manners manners to make a first-rate manager at 3-star hotels. And he is a top-notch streetfighter. And a ladykiller. And able to shrug off tortute.

I still enjoyed the book, but would have enjoyed it more if it had not gone all Bond.

No comments:

Post a Comment